Brain training to give tendon pain the boot

Footy player, netballer and ballet dancer available for interview

Re-training the brain with painless exercises may be the key to stopping recurring tendon pain, according to Melbourne researchers.

Dr Ebonie Rio

Dr Ebonie Rio

AFL, basketball and netball players are the major sufferers, with tendon pain in the knee debilitating and long-lasting. The injury can sideline a player or cause them to give up the sport entirely.

“More than 50 per cent of people who stop sport because of tendon pain still suffer from that pain 15 years later,” says Dr Ebonie Rio of the Monash University Tendon Research group.

“Our simple exercise is revolutionising how we treat tendinopathy.”

The treatment has been successful with a wide range of athletes, ranging from football players to ballet dancers. Among those successfully treated, are:

  • AFL footballer Darren Minchington (St Kilda)
  • Lead dancer Adam Bull (Australian Ballet)
  • Netballer Chloe Watson (Victorian Institute of Sport and Melbourne Vixens)
  • Basketball player David Barlow (Melbourne United)

All can testify to the effectiveness of the treatment.

Coined TNT (tendon neuroplastic training), the treatment combines stimulating the brain externally – for example by doing exercises to the sound of a metronome or voice-recording, rather than simply telling patients to hold a pose – with strength training, which is known to be good for tendons and muscles.

Ebonie and colleagues at the Monash University Tendon Research group found that a single, heavy bout of stationary exercise eliminated kneecap tendon pain instantly, lasting for up to 45 minutes. During the exercise, muscles are ‘on’ without being extended, and the joint is kept still – for example holding a weighted leg-extension in one spot.

Unlike movement-based treatments, which increase tendon pain (and so are harder for people to stick to), this is painless, as well as being medication- and-injection-free.

Elite athletes such as the AFL players Ebonie treats can complete TNT during training without worry of muscle fatigue – Ebonie even found the exercises increased muscle strength by 19 per cent immediately afterward.

“People with tendon pain have changes to the way they control their muscles, but our current exercises – and how they’re taught – don’t do enough to address the way the brain talks to muscles.

“This may be part of the reason why tendon pain is so persistent and often comes back.”

But Ebonie says the causes of tendon pain are still unknown, so any insights into the condition are welcomed.

“We have no idea what’s happening at a tendon level with tendon pain. Despite the fact that it can be chronic and persistent, it behaves quite differently to other types of chronic pain – for example back pain – in that it’s very localised within the tendon.”

During the stationary exercises, her team also monitored brain activity and were surprised to find high levels of muscle inhibition. “It’s as if their brain was trying to limit the use of their quadriceps – the muscles on the front of the thigh,” Ebonie says.

“We didn’t expect to see anywhere near that level of inhibition in people with tendon pain, so that was quite novel.”

Ebonie’s paper on tendon neuroplastic training will be published in the February volume of the British Journal of Sports Medicine next week.

After completing her PhD at Monash University, Ebonie has now started postdoctoral studies at the La Trobe Sport and Exercise Medicine Research Centre, where she will test the treatment on other tendons, as well as finding the minimum number of repeats needed to get lasting effects from the exercise.

Ebonie is a member of the Australian Centre for Research into Injury in Sport and its Prevention, and the research was partially funded by the Australia Institute of Sport Clinical Research Fund.

Ebonie was the Victorian winner of Fresh Science, a national program that helps early-career researchers find and share their stories of discovery. Fresh Science is in its 18th year and is helping to build a cadre of skilled Australian science communicators. In 2015, Fresh Science ran in every mainland state, with 180 early-career researchers nominating for the six Fresh Science events held this year in Melbourne, Townsville, Brisbane, Perth, Adelaide and Sydney.

Fresh Science Victoria was held at Scienceworks (media training), Melbourne Museum (schools forum) and the Kelvin Club (public event) and was supported by Museum Victoria, Biomedical Research Victoria and the Office of the Victorian Lead Scientist.

For interviews:
Ebonie Rio (Scientist) +61 414 885 270, e.rio@latrobe.edu.au

Media contacts:
Errol Hunt (Science in Public) +61 423 139 210, errol@scienceinpublic.com.au
Monash Media & Communications + 61 3 9903 4840, media@monash.edu
Leah Humphrys (La Trobe University) +61 3 9479 5353, l.humphrys@latrobe.edu.au

Dr Ebonie Rio

Dr Ebonie Rio

 

Leg extension machine

Leg extension machine

 

Set up of brain testing

Set up of brain testing

 

Electrodes record activity from the quadriceps muscle

Electrodes record activity from the quadriceps muscle

 

Ebonie Rio’s TNT paper “Tendon neuroplastic training: changing the way we think about tendon rehabilitation: a narrative review” will be published in the February volume of the British Journal of Sports Medicine

 

Australian ballet performer Adam Bull. Photo by Daniel Boud

Australian ballet performer Adam Bull. Photo by Daniel Boud

 

Recording from the muscle as the brain is stimulated. As intensity of stimulation increases, response (muscle twitch) also increases.

Patellar tendon pain is felt at the bottom of the knee cap and occurs in athletes that use that tendon like a spring, for example jumping in ballet, football and netball. Other tendon pain is common in athletes and non-athletes like in the Achilles.

Patellar tendon pain is felt at the bottom of the knee cap and occurs in athletes that use that tendon like a spring, for example jumping in ballet, football and netball.
Other tendon pain is common in athletes and non-athletes like in the Achilles.

 

People with patellar tendon pain have differences in the way they use the brake & accelerator that drives their quadriceps muscle. It is like they have one foot stuck on the accelerator and one foot stuck on the brake (like a learner driver!) The isometric exercise changes the brake & accelerator to allow them to perform painfree and stronger than before the exercise.

People with patellar tendon pain have differences in the way they use the brake & accelerator that drives their quadriceps muscle. It is like they have one foot stuck on the accelerator and one foot stuck on the brake (like a learner driver!) The isometric exercise changes the brake & accelerator to allow them to perform painfree and stronger than before the exercise.

 

Related Articles